Honest limits
What We Don't Know
Where the measurements stop, and the kinds of burning a crew or a sensor can miss.
Partial-gravity tests in the repository
0
combustion tests in lunar or Martian gravity. Every flight investigation in the catalogue ran in microgravity.
Source: official challenge brief, Flame in Freefall; PSI Data Repository search “combustion”
31.9%
highest oxygen of any solid-fuel test point
275 test points with a stated outcome
0 of 276
droplet tests with both CO2 and helium
NASA/TP-2015-216046, Table IX
39 of 60
n-heptane “extinctions” that kept burning
NASA/TP-2015-216046, Appendix B captions
Gap 1
Partial gravity
No repository dataset. The nearest real evidence is one suborbital flight and a few short ground tests.
Spread rate: simulated lunar gravity against normal gravity
One flight, preliminary slides. Lunar gravity came from spinning the capsule, so Coriolis force affects the flames.
- Simulated lunar gravity
- Normal gravity, same hardware
verified against the cited sourceSource: Ferkul et al., ASGSR 2025 presentation, slides 19, 33, 36 (NTRS 20250010653). A conference presentation, not peer reviewed, not a repository dataset. The PMMA values are printed as 0.15 and 0.40 cm/s. · open source
NO DATA
0
lunar- or Martian-gravity combustion datasets in the repository
Source: official challenge brief, Flame in Freefall
0.92mm/s
fabric flame-base spread in simulated lunar gravity, against 1.5 mm/s in normal gravity
Source: ASGSR 2025 presentation, slides 19, 33 (NTRS 20250010653)
2.3% O2
worst-case shift in flammability limit between normal and lunar gravity, five materials at 8.2 psia
Source: Urban et al., ICES-2025-392, Table 2 text (NTRS 20250002114)
Spread rate vs gravity is non-monotonic in the models and in low-conductivity-core wire tests, with a maximum and a minimum flammability O2 near lunar gravity; thin-cellulose KC-135 data at 0.2–0.4 atm are monotonic in g over 0.1–1 g. The peak location is material-, geometry- and pressure-dependent and is not yet fixed by a lunar-surface measurement — that is what FM2 is for.
Gap 2
Solid materials above the tested oxygen range
Each mark is one test point. The shaded band has no test; the dashed box is where future cabins are expected to sit.
- sustained
- quenched
- blown off
- no ignition
Source: 275 solid-fuel test points with a stated outcome: NASA/TM-20210011385 (BASS-II), PSI-99 table, Olson et al. 2023, ICES-2024-365, ICES-2025-156, NTRS 20240007628. Solid fuels only; droplet and gas tests are not on this chart. 243 of the 313 points have an assumed pressure: A pressure marked as assumed is not printed for that test. BASS-II tests outside the fabric table are taken as 1 atm (the memo states 1 atm for the fabric tests; the others ran in the same glovebox), and the Saffire VI Nomex sample is given its campaign's initial pressure. · open source
NO DATA
0
solid-material test points above 34% oxygen, at any pressure
Source: 275 solid-fuel test points
31.9%
highest oxygen with a recorded outcome: Saffire-VI Nomex, no ignition
Source: Niehaus et al., ICES-2025-156, Table 1 (NTRS 20250002675)
31.0%
highest oxygen with a sustained flame: Saffire-VI SIBAL-cotton at 54.1 kPa
Source: Urban et al., ICES-2024-365, Table 1
Gap 3
Carbon dioxide and helium together
Every FLEX test lies on one of the two axes. The two diluents were never combined.
- Methanol
- n-Heptane
Source: NASA/TP-2015-216046, Table IX. · open source
NO DATA
0
of 276 tests contain both gases
Source: NASA/TP-2015-216046, Table IX
123
tests with carbon dioxide
Source: NASA/TP-2015-216046, Table IX
51
tests with helium, at their own oxygen levels and pressures: its effect is unclear
Source: NASA/TP-2015-216046, Table IX
What you can't see · 1
Cool flames after the visible flame is gone
“Extinction” in the table means the visible flame. For n-heptane, the droplet often kept vaporising.
n-Heptane tests logged as Extinction (n = 60)
- Cool-flame evidence39
- No evidence8
- Unclear6
- Caption silent7
Source: NASA/TP-2015-216046, Appendix B figure captions: the authors' reading of continued vaporisation and a vapour cloud after the visible flame vanished. No methanol caption mentions a cool flame. · open source
39 of 60
kept vaporising after the flame disappeared. “No visible flame” is not “fire out”
Source: NASA/TP-2015-216046, Appendix B captions
What you can't see · 2
Smoke too fine for the detector
Geometric mean particle diameter by material, fresh and after 720 s, against the 500 nm mark.
- Fresh smoke
- After 720 s
verified against the cited sourceSource: Urban et al., SAME Final Report (NIST, 5 Mar 2010), Table 1 · read: full text · open source
The two flights used different hardware and diagnostics and their values differ by about a factor of two. They are kept as two tables and never averaged.
½ · ⅔
of Kapton and of Teflon smoke tests in which the station-type detector did not alarm
Source: Fire-detection white paper for the 2023-2032 Decadal Survey, p. 2 (summarising SAME results)
80nm
fresh Kapton smoke, against a 500 nm mark
Source: Urban et al., SAME Final Report (NIST, 5 Mar 2010), Table 1
981s
for a far-field detector to reach its alarm threshold in a vehicle-scale burn
Source: ICES-2024-365, p. 5 and Fig. 7
What you can't see · 3
Dim blue flames, and an oxygen figure that is not a cabin
Near its limit a flame shrinks and turns blue. And 85% O2 in the tables is a burner feed, never an ambient.
Near the limit, in the solid-fuel tests
the flame shrinks to a hemispherical blue flame and oscillates with increasing amplitude just before going out
verified against the cited sourceSource: NASA/TM-20210011385 §6.1.1 (report p. 64) · open source
Other gaps found while checking sources
A number that is quoted but could not be found, or a table that is not open.
A smoke-detection delay in microgravity compared with normal gravity, in seconds
No published number. The SAME report says lags are longer and gives none; Saffire gives absolute microgravity times only.
Source: SAME Final Report abstract; ICES-2024-365; ICES-2026-577
Cool-flame burning rates for n-heptane
No open table. Hot and cool rates are published for n-decane and n-octane only; Table IX gives hot-flame rates.
Source: NTRS 20140006750; NASA/TP-2015-216046
One-step cool-flame kinetic parameters fitted to FLEX (2012)
Not openly available. A later six-step model is open and is cited instead.
Source: Williams and Nayagam 2019 (open copy)
Numeric extinction or dilution limits for coflow and spherical gas flames
Qualitative statements only in every open source read.
Source: ACME overview, JASMAC-33 (NTRS 20210022542)
BASS-II extinction velocities for most rod and film tests
Recorded as fan settings; the memo prints no conversion to cm/s, so 100 of 290 test points have no velocity.
Source: NASA/TM-20210011385, Appendix A
Numbers that appear only in the 2019 BASS-II conference paper
Not re-read: the repository blocks automated access. Marked as not verified wherever they appear.
Source: ICES-2019-101
NO DATANothing on this page is filled in
Spacesuits are filled with 100% oxygen at 4.3 psi; the atmosphere used on the Moon will likely be 30% oxygen or more at 10.2 psi or less. Nothing in this data set speaks to the spacesuit condition. Source: Official challenge brief, Flame in Freefall.